Players Love Transforming Threats Into Tools
Games present players with threats to challenge them. Due to loss aversion, removing threats often feels more satisfying than gaining rewards. But even more appealing than removing a threat is finding ways to harness it for your benefit.
In Unrailed 2, many enemies you encounter can work to your advantage. Moles steal your stuff, but if you destroy their molehills, you can find rewards inside. Reindeer eat commodities, but also poop out high-value compacted versions. And sandworms try to eat you, but also destroy nearby terrain, opening new paths. Once you learn how they work, you can use most things in the game to your advantage.
The key to creating threats that players can learn to harness is often the use of externalities. Package bad with good, and players gain a reward once they learn to avoid the negative aspects. This is especially important for attacks between players. Take-that mechanics can drag down gameplay if they are purely destructive. Including constructive elements makes them feel more like challenges than disasters.
For example, in Carcassonne: Inns and Cathedrals, a common tactic is playing a cathedral on someone else's city. Not only does the city become harder to complete, but it is worthless if not finished by the end of the game. If the opponent succeeds despite the extra difficulty, however, they score bonus points. Attacks designed in this way are far more constructive than pure take-that mechanics.
When designing attacks or challenge systems, ask how players might exploit them. Few things in games are more gratifying than turning an obstacle to your advantage.
Comments ()